@mcmjolnir I recommend playing the one that speaks to you thematically. They're all enjoyable in their own way but when facets really click for you it's extra fun. For example, I'm a femme that studied a lot of classics/art history and Odyssey was ~perfect~ (one of? or the? first time the character could be a woman).
Never have but I loveloveloved Shadows of Mordor and think it'd scratch the same itch.